Newcastle out of Champions League after Milan loss

Newcastle United’s Champions League campaign ended in heartbreak on a night of emotion and drama on Tyneside, as AC Milan came from behind to win at St James’ Park and send them out of Europe.

It was an outcome that would have sent Newcastle through on head-to-head results against PSG – but the mood shifted in a matter of minutes just before the hour.

Teenager Warren Zaire-Emery equalised for the French champions in Germany, then former Chelsea forward Christian Pulisic levelled for Milan.

As both sides pushed for a winner in an open game, Milan keeper Mike Maignan did brilliantly to turn Bruno Guimaraes’ shot on to the woodwork before Rafael Leao raced clear for the Italians, only to shoot against the foot of the post.

Newcastle’s fate was sealed six minutes from time when Milan struck ruthlessly on the counter-attack, substitute Samuel Chukwueze curling a superb finish high past Martin Dubravka.

It left manager Eddie Howe and his players devastated following a return to the Champions League which was fiercely fought, but has ended with them bottom of Group F and without even the consolation of a place in the Europa League.

Newcastle regret what might have been

When the half-time whistle blew to a huge Tyneside roar, Newcastle were on course for the last 16 of the Champions League – but when a dramatic second half came to its conclusion they were out of Europe completely.

It summed up the swings in fortune on a night when attention was divided between what was unfolding at St James’ Park and events in Germany, followed closely to see what impact they had on Newcastle’s fate.

Newcastle’s destiny was out of their own hands after the controversial stoppage-time penalty which gave PSG a draw in Paris two weeks ago, but they were fulfilling their part of the bargain by dominating a lacklustre AC Milan side overawed by the intensity of their opponents and the atmosphere.

The problem was that Newcastle were always living on the edge and it so proved with those goals, first for PSG in Germany then Milan on Tyneside, which was the start of the downfall.

Newcastle did not create enough for all their possession, and were punished as they employed a high-risk strategy in the hope of creating the victory and the potential to go through.

It was not to be, and a campaign that brought the glory of the 4-1 thrashing of PSG in Newcastle’s first Champions League game on home soil in two decades, ultimately came up short with key moments being a crucial home defeat to Dortmund, that fateful penalty in Paris and this loss to Milan.

They have acquitted themselves well despite finishing bottom of their group, but this has been a brutal learning experience.

Howe must lift broken Newcastle

There was the sound of silence and a sense of disbelief for just a few seconds as the grim realisation of Newcastle’s elimination from European football sank in.

Newcastle had high hopes that the cards could fall in a way which would allow them to enjoy the prestige and financial firepower of the Champions League knockout phase. Instead they were beaten and looked broken after a chastening week.

They have been overpowered by Everton and Tottenham before losing to Milan in what was, at first, a smash-and-grab but ended with the Italians squandering chances, hitting the post twice as Newcastle chased an unlikely outcome.

Newcastle also looked, as they had done in those Premier League matches, exhausted at the final whistle.

Howe now has the task of lifting a leg-weary squad short on numbers because of injuries, into a position where they can sample this challenge next season – and show they have learned from it – by finishing in the Premier League’s top four.

There was no consolation in the manner of Newcastle’s demise. Now Howe faces a huge challenge to lift their spirits.